Making
The Most of Your Ride
and Attraction Budget
Jerry Merola, Chief Financial Officer
Amusement Entertainment Management, LLC
Inevitably, once all the hard work has been done with respect to
feasibility review, debt financing, land and building acquisition,
and marketing plan development, new facility developers must concentrate
their efforts on purchasing the necessary attractions and concessions
for their new facility. More often than not, the purchase process
can be more stressful than the phases that have come before it,
largely because of the need to meet opening deadlines, fixed budgets,
and space limitations.
Perhaps the biggest challenge facing most new developers is the
process of "coming in on budget". Few projects typically
provide for, or have the luxury of, a contingency allowance, which
would permit additional expenditures to occur as needed. Unfortunately,
unexpected costs do occur, particularly when attractions need to
be transported and installed within new facilities. Need an ADA
(Americans With Disabilities Act) compatible entry ramp and door
for each of your attractions? Add about $5,000 to each attraction's
budget. Need that 43-foot Tilt-A-Whirl shipped by truck to your
location? Add another $8,000. Need that motion simulator installed?
Factor in another $3,000. Before you know it, the original budget
starts to resemble the appetizer instead of the main course. What's
the solution to all of these "extra" costs? Consider the
option of purchasing some of your attractions in used or reconditioned
form. While this will require additional effort, the results can
be well worth the time investment. This past year, our firm has
sourced almost 70 used attractions for clients, some of which were
reconditioned, installed, and warranted by the original manufacturer.
The cost savings might surprise you.
Finding The Best Buys
There's no easy method to create an industry network of "equipment
scouts", but ultimately it can be done with some legwork. Many
of the equipment and attraction transactions that I've been a part
of in the past weren't triggered by a For Sale sign in the window,
but rather occurred as a result of general inquiries. Existing facility
owners tend to become interested in selling a ride or attraction
once they realize that a potential buyer is available. Others are
equally interested in "swapping" attractions with other
facility owners who maintain attractions within their facilities
that have exhausted their useful life at that location. Additionally,
there are many worthy attraction and ride resellers that service
the amusement marketplace, all of whom have the ability to source
needed equipment, many times within the geographic location in which
the seller is located. Not to be overlooked is the manufacturers
themselves, most of whom offer reconditioned units at substantial
savings over new units.
Seasonality plays a big factor in locating quality equipment. Don't
expect to find an abundance of highly desirable rides and attractions
at the start of the summer season. Shopping for these items should
occur in the early Fall, when many amusement parks and carnivals
are divesting themselves of equipment that has not made the cut
for the upcoming season. It may prove cheaper to purchase these
attractions off-season, store them for the winter months, and then
perform the installations at the appropriate time period. Many such
units can be stored in enclosed trailers right on the upcoming facility's
jobsite for as little as $50 per month.
Know What You're Buying
If you've decided to purchase some or all of your rides and attractions
in used or reconditioned form, it's important to know exactly what
is being purchased. Enlist the help of a knowledgeable industry
expert so that the risk of purchasing a "lemon" can be
minimized. What could go wrong? Here's a few real-life examples:
Missing Parts: Just like when you were a kid
opening presents during the holidays, there's always the risk that
parts may be missing. This becomes a bigger issue when purchasing
attractions that are not currently operating, such as units that
have been placed in storage. Whenever possible, set up an escrow
account with the seller, equal to perhaps 10% of the sale price,
to support the purchase of replacement parts if needed.
Incorrect Disassembly: Sometimes, the seller
of a ride or attraction takes the easy way out when dismantling
a unit that has been sold. Whenever possible, a factory or factory-trained
technician should be involved in disassembly procedures, particularly
with high-end simulators. Serious damage can occur if sensitive
units are not dismantled under a factory-approved sequence. Unfortunately,
damage resulting from disassembly probably won't become apparent
until after the unit is installed at the purchaser's location.
Lack of Maintenance: The paint may be new, but
are the mechanical systems in good order? Often, a well-maintained
older attraction may be a better buy than a newer, neglected, unit.
Ask for a service history from the seller, and if possible, contact
the manufacturer for any historical data they may have on the specific
unit.
Incorrect Specifications: Two rides may have
been built by the same manufacturer, contain the same features,
and carry the same asking price, but their electronic and mechanical
systems may be completely different. Many manufacturers have made
continuous improvements to their attraction offerings, most resulting
from actual in-the-field usage results. Structural members have
been reinforced, electronic controls have been upgraded, safety
equipment has been enhanced, and drive units have been modified
for longer life. Many unknowledgeable purchasers may believe they
are buying the same model unit as they observed at another facility,
when in fact the mechanical and control systems are completely different.
To guard against such disappointments, purchasers should carefully
study the evolution of the attraction being purchased, noting the
upgrades and design changes that have occurred over the months or
years in which the unit has been in operation.
Lack of Upgrades: At times, manufacturers upgrade
their existing units to better comply with state, federal, or general
safety regulations. Notices are typically sent to prior purchasers
advising of the availability of such upgrades, most of which are
available for a fee (if the unit is out of warranty). The burden
of performing such upgrades ultimately lands on the current owner
of the attraction. Some will perform the upgrades - some won't.
It's important to confirm what's been done and what remains to be
done. The manufacturer itself can be an excellent source for such
information, as all such upgrades should be documented via paid
invoices. Imagine purchasing a used ride only to find out that the
local ride inspector within your municipality will not approve its
use without first incorporating required safety upgrades. In the
past, some of these upgrades have included replacement of structural
supports and crossmembers that have become much more costly than
the purchaser bargained for. In the end, it might have been more
worthwhile to simply purchase the attraction new or have selected
one that had already been upgraded.
Overpaying: It's easy to get excited about a
used attraction or ride, particularly when it's priced at 30-50%
less than an equivalent new unit. But sometimes the hidden costs
make these purchases less attractive. Equipment dismantling, experienced
labor, trucking, storage, reconditioning, and installation costs
can quickly close the gap between a new and used unit, as some new
equipment manufacturers include many of these services at discounted
rates. Be sure to factor each of these variables into the purchase
decision and bid the attraction or ride at a price that fits its
general market value and your budget. Remember too, that it may
prove easier to finance a new ride or attraction than a used one.
Most importantly, when in doubt, take a pass. It's better to
have lost a gem than secured a lemon. This is one area of the
business where doing your homework always produces positive results.
Can't find the time to do it all? Bring in the pros - in the end,
they'll pay for themselves three times over.
|